Cold feet can end a hunt faster than a missed shot. Once numbness sets in, staying quiet, steady, and focused becomes much harder, so the right pair of insulated hunting boots is equipment you notice only when it works.
I compared 10 cold weather hunting boots across a practical spread: 200g to 1600g insulation, waterproof rubber and membrane designs, pac boots, leather hikers, and scent-control models. My goal was simple: match each boot to a real hunting style instead of assuming the highest gram number is always best.
This guide to the best insulated hunting boots covers tree-stand sits, active mountain miles, wet late-season hunts, and severe cold. I also explain where the product data is strong, where forum hunters raise fair concerns, and what to consider before you choose.
Top 3 Picks for Best Insulated Hunting Boots (September 2026)
Best Insulated Hunting Boots in 2026: Quick Overview
| Product | Key Specs | Buy |
|---|---|---|
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 |
|
Check Latest Price |
1. NORTIV 8 Waterproof Hiking Snow Boots — Best Budget Pick
NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Winter Snow Boots,Dark/Brown/Black/1,10
200g insulation
Waterproof construction
Removable washable insole
The Good
- Waterproof shell
- Comfortable out of box
- Good traction
- Removable insole
The Bad
- Extreme-cold toe performance
- Laces loosen
- Large toe box
The NORTIV 8 is the lowest-insulation boot in this group, but that is not a weakness when the hunt stays active or temperatures are only moderately cold. Its 200g layer is easier to pair with warmer socks, and the rubber outsole has the slip and abrasion resistance I want when the trail turns from dirt to slush.
I would use this as a budget winter boot for short sits, early-season cold snaps, and hunters who generate plenty of heat on the move. It is also a good first insulated boot because the removable insole makes it easier to fine-tune the fit, and customers commonly describe it as comfortable immediately.
The trade-off appears when you stop moving in genuinely severe cold. Some customer feedback reports cold toes at the extreme end, so I would not treat the quoted -25F claim as a comfort guarantee without the right sock and fit system. The toe box may feel roomy, which can be useful for thick socks or a problem if your foot needs a close hold.
That broad fit is the main reason to try the pair on with the socks you plan to hunt in. Break-in is generally easy, but laces may need a second tightening during a long day.
When the NORTIV 8 is the right choice
Choose it for a lower-cost 200g boot when your hunting includes more walking than standing still. It is also sensible for a broad foot or a hunter who wants a removable insole and does not need the warmth of a 1000g pac boot.
Skip it for a motionless late-season hunt where the forecast calls for sustained deep cold. In that setting, a heavier insulation package is a safer starting point.
When the NORTIV 8 is the wrong choice
The 5-pound listed weight and loose toe volume can make it less precise on steep, rocky ground. If you need a close heel lock or plan to cover long distances, the XPETI or Irish Setter offers a more hiking-oriented feel.
For a first pair, this is a sensible value test, not the warmest possible answer.
2. XPETI Thermator Mid-Rise Boots — Best for Active Hunting
XPETI Men’s Thermator Mid-Rise Waterproof Hiking Boot Insulated Non-Slip camouflage 9.5
XPETI-DRY membrane
7mm multi-directional lugs
EVA midsole
The Good
- Lightweight
- Ankle support
- Strong traction
- Moisture-wicking lining
The Bad
- Some waterproof failures
- Break-in may be needed
- Lining can fold
For a hunter who wants a lighter step, the XPETI Thermator is the most hiking-like option here. The XPETI-DRY membrane, moisture-wicking lining, and EVA midsole make it a practical boot for active days when insulation must not feel like dead weight.
The 7mm multi-directional lugs are a real selling point on loose soil, mud, and packed trail. I would reach for this style when I expect to cover ground, climb, or transition between different surfaces rather than sit still from first light until dark.
Fit and break-in deserve attention. The ankle support is useful, but some users report that the boot needs a short break-in period, and the lining can fold or bunch inside the shell. A thin merino or synthetic sock helps me check the fit before adding a heavy winter sock.
Most owners find it comfortable and value-oriented, but waterproofing is not unanimous. That mixed feedback is important if you expect prolonged exposure to wet grass, deep snow, or repeated stream crossings.
When the XPETI Thermator is the right choice
Pick the Thermator for an active hunter who values traction and a lighter feel over maximum warmth. It is a good bridge between a hiking boot and a cold-weather boot when the temperature is cool rather than severe.
It is also useful for hunters who need solid ankle support without the bulk of a full pac boot.
When the XPETI Thermator is the wrong choice
Do not select it solely because it is called insulated. The product data does not provide a gram weight, and the waterproofing complaints mean it is a riskier choice for a wet, stationary hunt.
For deep cold or long wet sits, choose a model with a clearly stated insulation weight and stronger rubber coverage.
3. MUCK Arctic Pro Insulated Boot — Best Extreme Cold Pac Boot
MUCK Men’s Arctic Pro Insulated Boot, Brown, Size 12(M)
2mm thermal foam
100% waterproof
EVA midsole
The Good
- Extreme cold warmth
- Complete waterproofing
- All-day comfort
- Strong traction
The Bad
- Bulky
- Hard to remove
- Heavier price tier
The MUCK Arctic Pro is the warmest-looking answer in this roundup, and the 2mm thermal foam under the footbed is a useful distinction. Feet lose heat from below as well as around the toes, so a warmer base layer matters when you are sitting on a cold stand or standing on frozen ground.
Its 100% waterproof neoprene construction is the kind of protection I want for slush, mud, and snow that would soak a leather or mesh upper. Customers also praise the EVA midsole, comfort over long periods, and Bob-Tracker outsole on mixed terrain.
The compromise is mobility. The boot is listed at 6.5 pounds, feels bulkier than a leather hiking boot, and can be difficult to pull off after a wet day when mud has worked around the comfort topline. That is normal for a pac boot, but it is a real cost if your hunt is mostly stalking.
It is better suited to hunters who value warmth and dryness over speed. The product feedback is unusually strong for both attributes, which is why it earns the editor’s choice spot for a static cold-weather setup.
When the MUCK Arctic Pro is the right choice
Choose it for the coldest conditions in the list, especially when moisture is part of the day. It is a strong pick for ice fishing, late-season stands, and hunters who sit or stand for hours.
The combination of thermal foam and waterproof rubber also makes it a practical choice for slushy ground where a membrane boot may be overworked.
When the MUCK Arctic Pro is the wrong choice
Avoid it if every hunt is a long, fast mountain approach. Its bulk and weight can make precise footing less comfortable, and removing it quickly is harder than with a low-profile lace-up.
It is also a poor fit for warm-weather use; too much insulation can turn a waterproof boot into a sweat chamber.
4. MUCK Woody Max Mossy Oak — Best for a Camo-First Design
MUCK Men’s Mossy Oak® Break Up Country™ Woody Max Boot, Brown, Size 11(M)
Extended rubber exterior
Waterproof barrier
Stretch-fit topline
The Good
- Warm and comfortable
- True-to-size fit
- Durable
- Strong waterproofing
The Bad
- Hot in mild weather
- Heavy
- Limited colors
The MUCK Woody Max is a hunting boot in the most literal sense, pairing an extended rubber exterior with Mossy Oak camouflage. Its Stretch-Fit binding helps the upper sit closely around the calf, keeping warmth in and reducing the loose, sloppy feel that can affect some neoprene boots.
Customer feedback is especially strong on comfort, waterproofing, and durability. I would use it for a cold, wet hunt where the camouflage pattern matters and the pace is moderate; the 4.5-pound listed weight is noticeable but not outrageous for this category.
The main limitation is temperature range. This boot can run hot when the day warms up, and the product data does not give a gram weight, so I would not choose it from insulation claims alone. The fit is described as true to size, but I would still wear the socks I expect to use in the field.
For a stationary or short-to-moderate-distance hunt, the rubber shell provides a dependable moisture barrier. For a long, hot approach, a lighter 600g or 800g lace-up may keep feet drier from the inside.
When the Woody Max is the right choice
Choose it when you want camouflage, waterproof protection, and a secure neoprene fit in one package. It is a natural fit for late-season hunters who spend more time in a blind or stand than moving constantly.
Its high customer rating and comfort reports make it a lower-risk choice than a generic winter boot.
When the Woody Max is the wrong choice
Do not pick it for a mild fall day or a long climb where heat buildup and weight will work against you. A lighter 600g or 800g lace-up is easier to regulate.
If you need a precise ankle fit on uneven rock, the Irish Setter’s leather upper is more supportive.
5. ROCKY Retraction 800G — Best Mid-Weight Lace-Up
ROCKY Retraction Waterproof 800G Insulated Outdoor Boot, Realtree Xtra, Size 9(W)
800g Thinsulate Ultra
Rocky Waterproof
Realtree Xtra camo
The Good
- Clear warmth level
- Waterproof shell
- Camo upper
- Durable construction
The Bad
- Rare leak reports
- Lacing can snag
- Interior wear
The ROCKY Retraction occupies a useful middle ground: 800g of 3M Thinsulate Ultra without the full height and weight of a 1200g or 1600g pac boot. That makes it a strong candidate for a hunter who wants substantial warmth but still needs to hike.
Rocky’s Guaranteed Waterproof construction and Realtree Xtra nylon upper are practical details in cold, wet country. The mid-calf design protects the lower leg from brush and snow, while the cement construction keeps the build straightforward and durable.
The honest downside is that not every customer reports a lifetime of waterproof performance. I would inspect the upper after heavy use, dry the boots away from direct heat, and avoid assuming a warranty label makes the membrane indestructible. The upper hooks can also make lacing less smooth, especially with gloves.
The 800g insulation is the headline spec I would use for comparison. It is warmer than 200g and 400g options but less insulated than the 1000g, 1200g, and 1600g boots in this list, so it fits a middle cold range rather than every winter day.
When the Retraction is the right choice
Pick it for a hunter who wants a recognizable insulation weight and a lace-up profile. It is a good compromise for mixed days with hiking, sitting, and changing weather.
Realtree camouflage is a practical bonus if you want your footwear to blend into a wooded setup.
When the Retraction is the wrong choice
It may be too warm for active late-season travel and not warm enough for prolonged exposure well below freezing. The reported lacing snag is a minor annoyance that becomes more significant with cold fingers.
If waterproof confidence is your first priority, the MUCK or LaCrosse rubber models have a simpler barrier story.
6. LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 18-Inch 1600G — Best for Tree Stands
LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 18″ Insulated Hunting Boots for Men Featuring Waterproof Rubber, 1600G Thinsulate, and EVA Footbed, Realtree Edge – 8 M
1600g Thinsulate Ultra
Natural rubber
Adjustable gusset
The Good
- Exceptional warmth
- Waterproof shell
- Active Fit
- Burly Pro traction
The Bad
- Limited ankle support
- Can feel slick indoors
- Sizing with socks
For a tree stand hunter, the 18-inch Alphaburly Pro makes a strong case for itself. The 1600g Thinsulate Ultra insulation is the highest stated weight here, and the natural rubber shell keeps water out during wet approaches and muddy access trails.
The Active Fit design and adjustable gusset help keep the boot close to the leg, which matters when you are climbing and shifting your weight. I also like the Burly Pro outsole for snow and mud, where a broad, aggressive footprint can be more useful than a narrow hiking profile.
This is not the boot I would choose for a long, uneven ridge walk. Some users report limited ankle support, and the 5-pound listed weight is substantial. Sizing needs care because a heavy sock takes up room and can change how securely the foot sits inside the tall rubber upper.
Inside a vehicle or on a smooth garage floor, the outsole can feel slick. That is not the same as poor field traction, but it is a reason to keep the boots off polished surfaces when you remove them.
When the Alphaburly Pro is the right choice
Choose it for a long static sit, a cold stand, or a wet hunt where warmth and height matter more than low weight. The 1600g rating is easy to understand and gives you a clear reason to keep this model for the coldest trips.
It is also a good choice for hunters who want a tall waterproof barrier rather than a low-cut membrane boot.
When the Alphaburly Pro is the wrong choice
Skip it for a high-mileage mountain hunt where ankle mobility and a lighter step are more important than maximum insulation. A 600g leather boot is less warm but more natural underfoot for long approaches.
If you have a narrow foot, try the fit before committing because some owners find the toe box less generous than expected.
7. ROCKY Sport Utility 1000G — Best All-Around Performer
ROCKY Sport Utility 1000G Insulated Waterproof Boot, Mossy Oak Break Up, Size 10(WI)
1000g Thinsulate Ultra
Rocky Waterproof
Sport Utility outsole
The Good
- Strong warmth
- Reliable waterproofing
- Minimal break-in
- Durable traction
The Bad
- Feet can sweat
- Allow room for thick socks
The ROCKY Sport Utility is the most balanced 1000g option in the roundup. It gives you a clearly stated 1000g of 3M Thinsulate Ultra, a Guaranteed Waterproof build, and a Sport Utility outsole designed for traction across varied terrain.
Customer reports mention warmth in cold conditions, comfort soon after purchase, and boots lasting for many years, including a report exceeding 20 years. That durability signal is more useful to me than a vague “heavy-duty” label because it suggests the outsole and upper are built for repeated use.
The tradeoff is heat management. 1000g insulation is a serious amount, and some users report sweating during extended activity. I would size with a little extra room for a thick sock, but I would not simply buy a dramatically larger pair; too much space can reduce warmth and encourage heel movement.
The boot weighs 6.1 pounds per pair in size 10 according to the product data, so this is not a featherweight approach shoe. It is better as a do-everything cold-weather boot for a hunter who values one dependable pair over a large footwear rotation.
When the Sport Utility is the right choice
Choose it for a hunter who wants 1000g warmth without moving all the way to a 1600g pac boot. It suits mixed terrain, severe cold, and hunters who prefer a familiar lace-up construction.
Its combination of insulation, waterproofing, and traction makes it a strong default recommendation for a broad cold-weather setup.
When the Sport Utility is the wrong choice
It can be too warm during high-output travel or mild conditions. If you routinely hike several miles before sitting, a 600g or 800g boot may regulate temperature better.
Make sure the fit is snug enough to prevent heel lift but roomy enough for your intended sock. That is where I would spend time in the store or on an indoor trial before a remote hunt.
8. LaCrosse Burly ZXT Scent Free — Best for Scent-Critical Hunts
LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 18″ Hunting Boots for Men Featuring Waterproof Rubber, Adjustable Gusset, and EVA Footbed, Optifade Marsh – 7
Natural rubber
Scent-free technology
Active Fit gusset
The Good
- Lightweight feel
- Complete waterproofing
- Secure fit
- Good wet traction
The Bad
- Not extreme cold alone
- Can be hard to remove
- Foot sweating
The LaCrosse Burly ZXT stands out for a different reason: scent-free technology in a natural rubber boot. The product data specifically calls out odor-reducing protection, which is useful when a hunt places a premium on keeping human scent from carrying near game.
At 2 pounds, this is the lightest-feeling option in the group. The Active Fit design, adjustable neoprene gusset, and EVA footbed give it a secure, cushioned feel, while the rubber construction provides complete waterproofing and good traction in mud and water.
It is not a substitute for deep-cold insulation. Customer feedback says it performs best in fall and summer and above 30°F, so I would not choose it for a long below-freezing sit without a tested sock and liner strategy. Mud buildup can also make the adjustable gusset harder to pull over the foot.
That makes this a seasonal specialist. I would pack it for a wet early-season or mild late-season hunt when scent control and lightness matter, rather than expecting the Burly ZXT to do the work of a 1200g or 1600g boot.
When the Burly ZXT is the right choice
Choose it for a wet, active hunt where scent management is a priority and temperatures are not extreme. The lighter feel is a real advantage for long walks, and the waterproof rubber is dependable around water.
It is also a useful option for hunters who dislike the heavy feel of traditional pac boots.
When the Burly ZXT is the wrong choice
Do not buy it as your only boot for a cold late-season trip. Add insulation through carefully chosen socks or choose a higher-gram model if the forecast is near or below freezing for hours.
If you hunt steep, rocky ground, the lighter rubber build may not provide the same controlled support as a full-grain leather boot.
9. ROCKY Blizzard Stalker 1200G — Best for Deep Cold and Snow
Rocky Men’s Blizzard Stalker Pro Hunting Boot,Brown/Black,9 M US
1200g Thinsulate Ultra
Rocky Waterproof
Multi-directional Blizzard outsole
The Good
- Deep-cold warmth
- Strong snow and ice traction
- Durable build
- All-day comfort
The Bad
- Sole feels less warm
- Thin insole
- Bulky
- Heavy feel
The ROCKY Blizzard Stalker is aimed at hunters who expect snow, ice, and very low temperatures. Its 1200g Thinsulate Ultra insulation, rubber vamp, Guaranteed Waterproof construction, and multi-directional Blizzard outsole form a package built for difficult footing.
Customer feedback reports warmth down to -25°F, and the outsole earns praise on snow and ice. I would put this near the top of the list for deep-cold conditions where a broad tread and serious insulation are more valuable than a low-profile hiking feel.
The lower half of the boot is not perfect. Some users find the sole less warm than the insulated upper, and the removable mesh PU footbed is thin. A better aftermarket insole or carefully managed liner setup may help, but I would test that before a long trip rather than assume the insulation number solves every cold spot.
The 4.5-pound listed weight and bulky shape can feel excessive for tree-stand use or fast travel. It is a specialist boot: strong when conditions are severe, less attractive when the day demands speed.
When the Blizzard Stalker is the right choice
Choose it for deep cold, snow-packed access, and hunters who need aggressive traction and 1200g warmth. It is one of the more direct answers to the question of what the warmest boots for extreme cold should prioritize.
I would favor it for a sit or slow-paced hunt over an all-day approach.
When the Blizzard Stalker is the wrong choice
It is not my pick for a high-output mountain day. The bulk, weight, and reported thin insole can undermine comfort when you are moving constantly.
If your cold exposure is moderate, a 600g or 800g lace-up will usually be easier to regulate.
10. Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12-Inch — Best Premium Leather Boot
Irish Setter Elk Tracker 12″ Mens Hunting Boot, Brown, 8
600g Thinsulate Ultra
GORE-TEX waterproofing
Goodyear Welt construction
The Good
- Premium leather
- Excellent ankle support
- Resoleable construction
- Comfortable from day one
The Bad
- Narrow toe box
- Short laces
- Heavy
- Premium cost
The Irish Setter Elk Tracker is the premium choice for hunters who would rather carry a well-supported leather boot than a tall rubber pac. Its full-grain leather upper, 600g of Thinsulate Ultra, and GORE-TEX waterproofing cover the three features I look for first: controlled support, useful warmth, and a proven membrane.
The Goodyear Welt construction and steel shank make this a boot intended for years of service rather than a single season. ScentBan technology and a removable comfort cork EVA footbed with memory foam add practical hunting details, while the Bulls-Eye Air Bob sole gives the boot an aggressive stance on rough ground.
Customer reports describe no real break-in period and warmth in extreme cold, including a report near -10°F. I would still treat that as one user’s field report rather than a universal temperature rating. Foot shape matters: the toe box may run narrow, and the laces may feel short if you need a very secure wrap.
This is the most expensive model in the list, and it weighs 5.4 pounds. In return, you get a resoleable construction and a leather upper that can be maintained, which can make the higher upfront cost easier to justify over a long ownership period.
When the Elk Tracker is the right choice
Choose it for a hunter who values ankle support, leather durability, and repairability more than minimum weight. The 600g rating is a smart middle level for active travel followed by a cold sit, and GORE-TEX gives the upper a familiar waterproofing story.
It is especially attractive for big-game and mountain hunters who expect uneven terrain and want a boot that can be resoled.
When the Elk Tracker is the wrong choice
Do not choose it if you need the warmest possible boot for hours of immobility. A 1200g or 1600g model has much more insulation, even if it gives up some ankle support.
The narrow toe and short laces are also important for wide feet or hunters who use a thick sock plus a heavy footbed. I would make fit the deciding factor before price or brand.
How to Choose the Best Insulated Hunting Boots?
The best insulated hunting boots are the ones that match your temperature, movement, moisture, and fit. A 1600g boot sounds safer than a 600g boot on paper, but too much insulation can make an active hunter sweat, wet the liner, and then become cold anyway.
Insulated boots work by trapping warm air in a synthetic layer, commonly Thinsulate or a similar material, while a waterproof membrane or rubber shell slows external moisture. Fit, sock choice, boot care, and the amount of time you spend still determine whether that protection feels warm in the field.
Match insulation weight to the hunt
Use 200g insulation for active hunts and cool conditions where your body produces substantial heat. Consider 400g as a flexible middle option for changing weather, and move toward 800g when cold exposure increases or the hunt includes more sitting.
Choose 1000g to 1200g for deep cold, late-season work, and prolonged stands. A 1600g pac boot is best for severe cold, wet conditions, or hunters who generate little heat because they are mostly stationary.
The gram number describes insulation weight, not a guaranteed temperature. Wind, moisture, sock thickness, boot fit, blood flow, and time spent sitting all change the result.
Choose waterproofing for the ground you cover
A waterproof membrane in a leather or nylon boot is lighter and more breathable than a full rubber shell, but it needs sensible care and can be overwhelmed by repeated deep-water exposure. Full rubber or neoprene is a stronger barrier for mud, slush, and wet vegetation.
Waterproofing alone does not make a boot warm. If perspiration cannot escape, the liner becomes damp and insulation loses much of its value, so I would balance waterproof protection with the activity level and temperature.
Fit matters more than the logo
Try boots on with the socks and footbed you will use in the field. Your heel should stay secure, toes should not press into the front on a downhill walk, and the instep should feel supported without cutting off circulation.
Wide feet may prefer the roomier NORTIV 8, while the Irish Setter’s narrow toe can reward a closer fit. A thick sock can require extra volume, but too much empty space creates a cold pocket and encourages blisters.
Match the sole to your terrain
Deep, multi-directional lugs help in mud, snow, and soft ground. A more structured hiking sole and steel shank can feel more controlled on rock, roots, and steep trails.
For tree stands, prioritize warmth, height, and a secure fit. For mountain travel, prioritize weight, ankle support, and a sole that inspires confidence on uneven approaches.
Plan for break-in and maintenance
Leather boots often need a gradual break-in, while many rubber and insulated models feel comfortable sooner. The Irish Setter is reported to be comfortable from day one, and the NORTIV 8 is generally easy to live with, but individual feet still differ.
Dry wet boots at room temperature, remove insoles when needed, and store them loose rather than clamped around a heater. Clean mud from the outsole, inspect the upper and membrane, and replace worn insoles before the liner becomes the weak point.
Set a budget without buying the wrong tool
Budget models can work well for cool, active days, but severe cold often justifies spending more on insulation, a reliable waterproof system, and construction that can handle repeated wear. Premium leather boots can make sense when support and resoling extend their useful life.
Focus on the conditions you actually face. I would rather buy one correctly matched 800g or 1000g boot than own a cheap 1600g pac boot that is too heavy for the way I hunt.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the warmest hunting boots on the market?
The warmest choices here are the LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 1600G and the ROCKY Blizzard Stalker 1200G. The MUCK Arctic Pro is another strong extreme-cold option because it adds 2mm thermal foam under the footbed and a fully waterproof build. Warmth still depends on fit, socks, moisture, and how long you remain stationary.
Are insulated hunting boots worth it?
Yes, insulated hunting boots are worth it when cold exposure, late-season conditions, or long periods of sitting would otherwise make your feet cold. They can be excessive for warm, active hunts, where sweating and damp liners can reduce comfort. Match the insulation weight to the temperature and activity instead of buying the warmest pair available.
What are the warmest boots for extreme cold?
For extreme cold, start with 1000g to 1600g insulation, a waterproof shell, and enough volume for proper socks. The LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 1600G, ROCKY Blizzard Stalker 1200G, and MUCK Arctic Pro are the strongest cold-weather choices in this roundup. Test your fit and sock system before relying on any temperature claim.
Are insulated Hunter boots good for winter?
Insulated rubber Hunter-style pac boots are good for winter when waterproofing, height, and warmth matter more than a light, flexible feel. Models such as the MUCK Arctic Pro and LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro suit wet, cold, or stationary hunts. They can run hot and feel bulky during long, active travel.
Final Verdict on the Best Insulated Hunting Boots
For most cold-weather hunters, the ROCKY Sport Utility 1000G is the most balanced choice because it combines a clear 1000g insulation level, waterproof construction, traction, and a durable build. I would pick the MUCK Arctic Pro for the coldest, wettest static hunts, and the LaCrosse Alphaburly Pro 1600G when maximum insulation and height are the priority.
For active mountain hunters, the Irish Setter Elk Tracker is worth considering because its leather support and resoleable construction reward a closer fit. The right decision is the pair that keeps you warm without making you sweat, and the final choice should come down to temperature, terrain, moisture, and fit.